Loading car advice...
Loading car advice...

SHOWDOWN
Small Wonders: A Tale of Two City Cars
The Vauxhall Star City takes the crown in the battle of city cars, proving that size isn’t everything when you’ve got style and zippiness on your side! We compared the Vauxhall Star City and Toyota Aygo, evaluating comfort, design, performance, and tech features. The Star City shines with its modern curves and lively engine, while the Aygo, though quirky and reliable, feels a bit cramped and less exciting. For urban adventurers, the Star City is the ultimate sidekick!
| Styling | Comfort & Space | Performance | Tech & Infotainment | Overall | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vauxhall Star-City | 7 | 8 | 7 | 8 | 30 |
| Toyota Aygo | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 24 |
Is it right for you?
The winner on paper might not be the winner for your life.
In the bustling jungle of city life, where parking spots are as rare as full fuel tanks and where a car’s size can make or break a road trip, the Vauxhall Star City and Toyota Aygo strut their stuff as two mighty contenders in the city car arena. Both boast compact designs, nifty tech features, and that all-important user-friendly charm. But which one is the better sidekick for your urban adventures? Buckle up, as we take a ride through the twisty turns of comfort, style, performance, and more! Learn more about the Vauxhall Star City and get details on the Toyota Aygo.

Vauxhall Star-City
7
Toyota Aygo
6
The Vauxhall Star City has a slightly more contemporary look compared to the Aygo, which, bless its heart, sports a design that's still trying to keep up with the cool kids of the block. The Star City features smooth lines with a small yet aggressive front, making it adorable in a way that's somehow more... well, confident than the Aygo. Meanwhile, the Aygo embraces quirkiness with a ‘fun-size’ attitude, but may come off as an acquired taste aesthetically.
Both cars have their charm, but the Vauxhall Star City’s modern curves give it a slight edge in the style department. Compare Vauxhall Star City trims and explore Toyota Aygo trims.
Vauxhall Star-City
8
Toyota Aygo
6
Stepping into the Vauxhall Star City feels like entering a cozy lounge with its modern dashboard and quality materials, while the Aygo’s cabin has that 'let’s make use of every inch' vibe, resulting in not-so-fancy hard plastics and an overall basic feel.
In terms of space, the Star City provides a comfy environment for both driver and passengers, albeit not infinite space. The Aygo, on the other hand, has a cabin and boot size that might leave you feeling more like a sardine than a city car driver, especially if you take your shopping spree too seriously.
For comfort and space, Vauxhall takes the gold with its more inviting atmosphere, while the Aygo plays the minimalistic and efficient card, which might just fit perfectly for solo city explorers.

Vauxhall Star-City
7
Toyota Aygo
6
The Vauxhall Star City is poised and ready with a zippy engine that makes city driving feel like a game of speed, while the Aygo relies on its trusty old 1.0-litre three-cylinder engine that doesn’t quite have the same pep. The Aygo is reliable, but the Star City has that little bit more excitement under the hood.
Driving the Star City feels sharper, with better handling and road manners, allowing you to tackle those downtown bends like a pro. The Aygo, while still a fun drive, sometimes makes you wish for a bit more enthusiasm in its responses.
Both cars are surprisingly easy to maneuver in tight spots, but the Star City does come with additional modern features that give it a slight techy advantage over the Aygo’s simplicity.
Check finance options
Monthly payments, no commitment
Which one suits you?
Get a personalised answer from Bobi

Vauxhall Star-City
8
Toyota Aygo
6
The Star City comes equipped with a fun tech package that doesn't leave you yearning for the latest gadgets, while the Aygo’s infotainment system is more basic and might feel dated, even to the least tech-savvy drivers.
Both cars have their share of driver aids, but Vauxhall's clever tech enhances the driving experience more effectively than the Aygo’s simpler offerings.
Boot space is a less than exciting affair in both, but the Star City shines slightly brighter, offering just a tad more room to stash your bags—or that one awkwardly large plant from the nursery.
Vauxhall Star-City
Overall
30
Toyota Aygo
Overall
24
BOBI'S VERDICT
Both the Vauxhall Star City and Toyota Aygo are reasonably priced for what you get, but you may find the Star City offers slightly better value considering its more modern capabilities, starting from around £12,000, competing closely with the Aygo’s prices, which hover similarly.
In wrapping up this spirited tête-à-tête between the Vauxhall Star City and Toyota Aygo, it's clear the Star City is an appealing option for those seeking a modern, well-equipped city car that blends style and functionality. The Aygo, while endearing in its own right, may not have quite the same glitz as it once did. If you want to be the cool cat in the city without sacrificing comfort, performance, or tech, the Vauxhall Star City is the one to take for a spin! Explore used Vauxhall Star City listings and check out used Toyota Aygo listings.
Vauxhall Star-City
Overall
30
Toyota Aygo
Overall
24
When it comes to performance and driving experience, the Vauxhall Star City gives a more dynamic experience that could make your everyday commute a bit more exhilarating.
Tech-savvy drivers will appreciate the Vauxhall Star City’s modern features and infotainment setup over the Aygo, which, while functional, echoes an older generation of city cars.