Loading car advice...
Loading car advice...
SHOWDOWN
Battle of the Hot Hatches: Who Reigns Supreme?
The Mercedes-AMG A 45 S claims the crown in the hot hatch showdown, blending blistering performance with a touch of elegance that leaves the competition in the dust. We tested the Mercedes-AMG A 45 S, Audi RS3, and Volkswagen Golf R, evaluating performance, practicality, and pizzazz. The A 45 S dazzles with its 415bhp engine and Drift mode, while the RS3 charms with its tech-savvy interior and spacious cabin. The Golf R, though slightly less powerful, is the ultimate fun machine for daily driving.
Volkswagen Golf-R
From £13,999
| Styling | Comfort & Space | Performance | Tech & Infotainment | Overall | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mercedes-Benz Amg-A-45-S | 8 | 7 | 9 | 9 | 33 |
| Audi Rs-3 | 9 | 8 | 8 | 8 | 33 |
| Volkswagen Golf-R | 7 | 9 | 8 | 7 | 31 |
Is it right for you?
The winner on paper might not be the winner for your life.
Welcome, car enthusiasts and speed demons! Today, we’re diving into the thrilling world of hot hatches, where speed, style, and a sprinkle of fun collide. We’ll pit the Mercedes-AMG A 45 S, Audi RS3, and Volkswagen Golf R against each other in a showdown of performance, practicality, and pizzazz. Buckle your seat belts, it’s going to be a wild ride!
Mercedes-Benz Amg-A-45-S
8
Audi Rs-3
9
Volkswagen Golf-R
7
The A 45 S presents an understated aggression with minimal exterior changes, showcasing sleek lines and a sporty demeanor. The RS3, however, flaunts a flamboyant facade with bold bumpers and distinct features like the Kyalami Green finish. The Golf R keeps things somewhat low-key but brims with character thanks to its aggressive new front and the audacious tailpipe arrangement.
While the RS3 takes the crown for striking looks, the A 45 S holds its own with elegance, and the Golf R remains appealing, though it might need to dial down the noise.
Mercedes-Benz Amg-A-45-S
7
Audi Rs-3
8
Volkswagen Golf-R
9
The interiors across these models are plush, with luxurious materials and thoughtful layouts. The A 45 S combines sporty touches with an executive feel, while the RS3 offers a high-tech cockpit that feels both premium and practical. The Golf R, while modern, might not have that 'supercar' vibe but delivers solid comfort.
Each car ensures a comfortable ride for both drivers and passengers. The RS3 excels with its spacious cabin, while the Golf R provides ample cargo space. The A 45 S is slightly tighter but still maintains an enjoyable atmosphere.
If space and comfort are priorities, the Golf R is your best bet, with the RS3 being a close second and the A 45 S trailing slightly in this department.
Mercedes-Benz Amg-A-45-S
9
Audi Rs-3
8
Volkswagen Golf-R
8
The A 45 S's 2.0-liter engine churns out an impressive 415bhp, while the RS3's 2.5-liter five-cylinder pumps out 394bhp. The Golf R, though slightly less potent at 326bhp, remains a formidable competitor on the road.
The AMG A 45 S shreds corners with menacing precision, thanks to its sophisticated AWD system and Drift mode for those feeling cheeky. The RS3 offers a refined balance of performance and comfort, with a playful side when needed. The Golf R, with its direct engagement and fierce grip, proves to be a delightful driving companion.
All three come equipped with advanced driving systems. The AMG's Drift mode and the RS3's torque vectoring system enhance dynamics, while VW's adaptive features maintain a lively spirit throughout your drive.
Check finance options
Monthly payments, no commitment
Which one suits you?
Get a personalised answer from Bobi
Mercedes-Benz Amg-A-45-S
9
Audi Rs-3
8
Volkswagen Golf-R
7
The A 45 S boasts an advanced infotainment system with a sleek interface, making tech fun and user-friendly. The RS3 offers a high-quality digital cockpit that practically sings at you, while the Golf R's revamped touchscreen is an improvement but still has a bit of grumpiness at times.
Driver aids abound in all three contenders, with features that ensure safety and convenience, although the A 45 S edges ahead with a more integrated tech suite.
The Golf R, with its practical hatchback design, offers the most trunk space for the weekend trips, while the RS3 and A 45 S are decent but don’t quite have that utility.
Tech-wise, the A 45 S leads the pack, with the RS3 not too far behind. The Golf R still impresses, though it feels slightly behind the curve.
Mercedes-Benz Amg-A-45-S
Overall
33
Audi Rs-3
Overall
33
Volkswagen Golf-R
Overall
31
BOBI'S VERDICT
In terms of cost, the A 45 S hovers around the £50,000 mark, the RS3 is around £54,000 for a decked-out model, and the Golf R starts at about £43,895, making it the most accessible of the three. However, value for money should also consider the features and performance offered.
Choosing the right hot hatch depends on your priorities. If you want raw power and want to shred some roads, the Mercedes-AMG A 45 S is your beast. Opt for the Audi RS3 if you’re looking for a balance of performance and everyday flair. However, the Volkswagen Golf R, with its practicality and thrilling dynamics, offers an exceptional value as a well-rounded entry into this esteemed group.
Mercedes-Benz Amg-A-45-S
Overall
33
Audi Rs-3
Overall
33
Volkswagen Golf-R
Overall
31
For raw performance, the A 45 S takes the trophy, followed by the RS3 and then the Golf R, which, while powerful, focuses more on being an all-round fun machine.