Loading car advice...
Loading car advice...

SHOWDOWN
When it comes to the Audi S5 and BMW M4, it's a showdown of speed and style!
In the epic showdown of speed and style, the BMW M4 takes the crown, thanks to its blistering performance and aggressive design that screams “look at me!” We tested the Audi S5 and BMW M4, evaluating their performance, design, comfort, and tech features. The M4’s 523bhp twin-turbo straight-six catapults it from 0-60 in just 3.5 seconds, while the S5 offers a more refined ride with its elegant interior. Both are fantastic, but the M4 is the thrill-seeker's dream!
| Styling | Comfort & Space | Performance | Tech & Infotainment | Overall |
|---|
| Audi S5 | 8 | 8 | 7 | 9 | 32 |
| BMW M4 | 9 | 7 | 9 | 8 | 33 |
Is it right for you?
The winner on paper might not be the winner for your life.
Buckle up, folks! Today, we're diving into the world of performance saloons, where the Audi S5 and BMW M4 go head-to-head like two titans in a car enthusiast’s arena. Both are stunning machines equipped to thrill, but each has its unique flair. Let's see who wears the crown and who merely waves from the sidelines!

Audi S5
8
BMW M4
9
The Audi S5 sports a sleek, almost quintessentially German aesthetic with a touch of modern flair; think sharp lines and an elegant silhouette. Meanwhile, the BMW M4 takes a more aggressive stance, flaunting its massive kidney grille and an overall design that shouts, 'Look at me!' in vibrant hues like the showy Sao Paulo yellow. These cars don’t just go fast—they turn heads doing it!

Audi S5
8
BMW M4
7
The Audi S5's interior boasts high-quality materials, ergonomic design, and a technologically advanced cockpit that makes even the mundane drives feel like a luxurious experience. Plush seating and a custom vibe make it an inviting space. In contrast, the BMW M4 leans towards sportiness; while the interior is functional and stylish, it’s more geared toward performance enthusiasts than the casual cruise.
While the Audi S5 offers ample legroom and a user-friendly layout, the M4 can feel a bit snug, especially with its sport-oriented styling. Both offer decent cargo space for their class, but be prepared to stumble if you rear-end the M4!

Audi S5
7
BMW M4
9
The Audi S5 is powered by a smooth 3.0-litre V6 TFSI engine, delivering a spirited 362bhp, whisking you from 0-60 mph in about 4.5 seconds. While this isn't too shabby, the BMW M4 packs a serious punch with a 3.0-litre twin-turbo straight-six, cranking out 523bhp and achieving 0-60 in a blistering 3.5 seconds.
When it comes to driving dynamics, the M4 takes the biscuit. Its superior grip and razor-sharp handling make it a joy on twisty backroads. The S5, while competent, feels a bit more subdued; it's the dependable friend on a weekend getaway rather than the wild party animal. The AWD in the S5 means it’s got traction in spades, but the M4 invites you to push the limits, all while enjoying a performance that can excite even the seasoned driver.
Check finance options
Monthly payments, no commitment
Which one suits you?
Get a personalised answer from Bobi

Audi S5
9
BMW M4
8
The Audi S5 dazzles with its spacious infotainment layout, featuring a high-resolution touchscreen and great usability that makes setting up your road trip playlist a breeze. The BMW M4’s tech is equally impressive but slightly less intuitive, which might leave you fidgeting with gadgets rather than enjoying the open road.
Driver aids on the S5 include all the gizmos you’d expect, from adaptive cruise control to a bevy of safety features. The M4 counters with features like the M Drift Analyzer—sure to appeal to those with a penchant for performance driving and a touch of mischief!
Audi S5
Overall
32
BMW M4
Overall
33
BOBI'S VERDICT
The Audi S5 starts at around £68,700, which is a competitive price point for a performance saloon. The BMW M4, however, has climbed to a hefty starting price of about £87,495 as it leans into its role as the more premium option.
In the battle of the Audi S5 versus the BMW M4, it's clear each has its audience. The Audi S5 wins in comfort, tech, and everyday usability, but for those chasing thrills and an exhilarating drive, the BMW M4 pulls ahead with impressive performance and sporty dynamics. If you're looking for a car that smooths out the bumps of daily life, the S5 is your buddy. But if you want a thrilling ride that makes your heart race, the M4 is the beast you want to tame!
Audi S5
Overall
32
BMW M4
Overall
33
Overall, the Audi S5 takes the cake for comfort and usability, ensuring every journey is a chill ride, whilst the BMW M4 prioritizes performance thrills at the expense of a little elbow room.
Both cars come loaded with modern tech: the S5 features sporty adaptive dampers and all-wheel-drive, while the M4 comes with customizable driving modes and some nifty performance aids to help you strut your stuff.
With a clear edge in thrill and driving prowess, the BMW M4 steals the spotlight here, but the Audi S5 is still a solid performer when you want power without the wild side.
Both vehicles offer reasonable cargo capacity for everyday errands, but the S5’s slightly larger trunk could make a difference when packing for a weekend getaway.
The Audi S5 boasts superior tech and an easier-to-use interface. If you're a gadget lover, it’ll keep you entertained. The M4, while techy, leaves you feeling like you’re trying to open a can with a lion’s claw—fun but not always easy!